Renting Isn’t Throwing Money Away - And Buying Isn’t Always Smart

Your friend just posted their new house on Instagram, and suddenly you're wondering if you're behind. Should you be buying instead of renting? Is renting just "throwing money away"? In this episode, Maddie and Meghan break down the real costs of renting versus owning - beyond just the mortgage payment - and help you figure out what actually makes sense for YOUR life. This isn't about what looks good on paper or what everyone else is doing. It's about making the housing decision that supports your goals, timeline, and values. Plus, Meghan shares the real story of her first condo purchase and whether it was actually a smart move.

Listener Review

From "On my money journey" on Apple Podcasts: "I am loving the content! So many useful and quick tips that I have been able to implement in my money journey!"

Thank you so much! This is exactly why we do this show - to give you practical tools you can actually use. If you're loving the podcast too, we'd be so grateful if you left us a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It helps other people find the show, and we might share yours on the podcast too!

What You'll Learn in This Episode About Buying vs Renting

The "American Dream" Pressure Homeownership has long been framed as the ultimate success marker, creating pressure from family, friends, and social media. The narrative says you're not a "real adult" until you own.

The Reframe: A home is a lifestyle decision, not just a financial one. Your housing choice should support YOUR life, not meet someone else's expectations.

Meghan's teaser: "I'm going to tell you the real story of my first condo purchase and whether it was actually a smart move."

It's Not One-Size-Fits-All There's no "right" answer for everyone. The right choice depends on your goals, timeline, location, cash flow, and whether you value flexibility or stability more right now. This decision can change over time - what's right now might not be right in 5 years.

Key insight: "The best decision is the one that supports the life you want - not the one that looks best on paper."

The Real Cost of Renting

What you actually pay:

• Monthly rent payment

• Renters insurance (national average: $13/month)

• Utilities (depending on lease)

Your rent is the MAXIMUM you'll pay each month - predictable and capped.

Example: $2,000 rent + $13 insurance + $150 utilities = $2,163 total ceiling.

What you DON'T pay: repairs, maintenance, property taxes, HOA fees, homeowners insurance, or unexpected major expenses.

The Real Cost of Owning

Critical truth: Mortgage ≠ total housing cost. Your mortgage is just the STARTING POINT.

What you actually pay monthly:

1. Mortgage (principal + interest) - In early years, most is interest, not equity

   • $500K home at 6.1% interest: First 10 years = $229K interest, only $64K principal

2. Property taxes - $400-600/month on $400K house (varies by location, often higher in no-income-tax states)

3. Homeowners insurance - $100-300+/month (rising in FL, CA, TX)

4. HOA fees (if applicable) - $100-500+/month

5. Maintenance - Budget 1-2% of home value annually ($333-667/month on $400K home)

6. Utilities - Often higher in houses than apartments

Real Example - $500K house, 20% down:

• Mortgage: $2,442/month

• Property taxes: $500/month

• Insurance: $125/month

• Maintenance: $250/month

• Utilities: $250/month

• Total: $3,567/month minimum

Plus: $500K home at 6.168% interest = $978K total spent including all interest over the loan life.

Stability vs. Flexibility Tradeoff

Buying = Stability Benefits: Control your space, customize, stay long-term, build equity, predictable payment, emotional security Tradeoffs: Less flexibility to move, maintenance burden, capital tied up

Renting = Flexibility Benefits: Easy to relocate, lower upfront costs, no maintenance responsibility, test neighborhoods, keep cash liquid Tradeoffs: Landlord could sell, lease may not renew, rent can increase, can't customize fully, not building home equity (though you can build wealth other ways)

Key insight: "Both are valuable - you just need to know which you're prioritizing in this season. And that priority can change."

Why Timeline Matters

The rule: Plan to stay AT LEAST 7 years for buying to make financial sense. (Lower interest rates can mean shorter timelines - use mortgage calculators and consult a lender.)

Years 1-3: Closing costs (2-5%), most payments go to interest, minimal equity built. If you sell: costs eat most gains.

Years 4-7: Building meaningful equity, likely broken even on closing costs. This is the break-even zone.

Years 7+: Coming out ahead - enough equity built, appreciation working, selling costs won't wipe out gains.

Real scenario: Buy a house, live 2 years, move for work. You paid $20K closing costs, built $10K equity, pay $24K to sell (6% on $400K). You've lost $34K even if the house didn't lose value.

Hidden Factors People Forget

Opportunity cost: $100K down payment invested at 8% for 10 years = $216K vs. $100K in home equity at 3% appreciation = $134K. Home equity isn't the only way to build wealth.

Rising costs: Property taxes increase over time (not fixed like mortgage). Insurance costs rising, especially in climate-risk states. Maintenance requires time, money, AND mental energy.

Market reality: Homes don't always appreciate (see 2008 crisis). Your money is tied up - can't easily access without selling or taking a loan.

The reframe: "Homeownership builds wealth for SOME people in SOME situations - but it's not the only way. And it's not always the BEST way."

When Buying vs. Renting Makes Sense

Buying Probably Makes Sense If: ✅ Staying 7+ years ✅ Stable income + 3-6 month emergency fund + 20% down saved (don't drain all savings) ✅ Want control/customization ✅ Value stability over flexibility right now ✅ Full ownership costs fit comfortably in budget (not house-poor) ✅ Buying because you want to, not from pressure ✅ Ready for maintenance responsibility

Renting Probably Makes Sense If: ✅ Might move in 3-5 years ✅ Career/life in flux ✅ Still building emergency fund or don't have 20% down ✅ Value flexibility and mobility ✅ Want to invest money elsewhere (retirement, brokerage, business) ✅ Don't want maintenance responsibility ✅ Market is overheated or uncertain ✅ Buying would make you house-poor ✅ Want capital liquid for other opportunities

Key message: "Neither is 'better' - they're different tools for different seasons. The right tool might change in 5 years. That's okay."

Final Takeaway

Renting is NOT "throwing money away" - you're paying for flexibility, lower risk, liquidity, and maintenance-free living.

Buying is NOT automatically smart - it depends on your situation, timeline, and market.

Both can be intentional, wealth-building choices.

"The smartest housing decision is the one that supports YOUR life - not someone else's expectations. Make the choice that gives you the freedom, stability, or flexibility you need right now. That's the win."

Your Action Steps

🏠 Assess your timeline: Do you see yourself staying in your area for 7+ years?

💰 Calculate real costs: Use the examples in this episode to estimate TOTAL monthly ownership costs (not just mortgage)

📊 Consider opportunity cost: What could that down payment do if invested elsewhere?

🎯 Define what YOU value: Stability or flexibility right now? (Both are valid!)

📝 Check your finances: Emergency fund + 20% down payment + room in budget for full ownership costs?